Its a bizarre copy there are no publishing notes at all. Between the book and the film there is also a difference in the time of. A man of science, who sought to create a man after his own image, without reckoning upon god. It is also of note that whales handling of the film also adds a bit of class. Comparison between the film and the book frankenstein. Best frankenstein film that was closest to the mary shelley book. Upon placing a brain inside the head of the monster. Frankenstein 1931 film is based on the book of the same name by mary shelley.
None of these films even remotely followed the original novels storyline, and none ever achieved the kind of fame garnered by the original movie. In the book, marry shelley described everything in great detail. In both mary shelleys gothic novel frankenstein and mel brooks movie young frankenstein, frankenstein, the protagonist, is a scientist whose obsession with power and reanimation take over his life. Some of them are better than others, but only the first three star. The body is raised to the ceiling and all the electrical equipment is engaged. They travel together and after they get themselves into trouble in the city of weed, they moved to work on a ranch. And finally, the names were changed from the novel to the book. The difference between the book mary shelly frankenstein and the 1931 frankenstein movie. This article is a compare and contrast essay between frankenstein novel vs. Anyone who has read mary shelleys frankenstein and seen james whale s 1931 film version knows that the similarities between the two are minuscule at best, while the differences abound. Not only looking at the film, but also how it follows or differs form the book, its place in history and influence on subsequent frankenstein films.
There, frankenstein tells the tale of how he got here, turning the entire book into one long flashback. An obsessed scientist assembles a living being from parts of exhumed corpses. Also, does mary shelley write in a similar manner to other female authors of that time period. Henry frankenstein, who creates a monster, by taking body parts from dead people. He succeeds at creating life from deatha creature in the semblance of a manbut is horrified by the result. The creation sequence is a highlight of the film and a masterpiece of special effects work for its time. The difference between the book mary shelly frankenstein and. The two films i will be addressing in this essay are kenneth branaghs and james whales versions of frankenstein, a horror novel written by mary shelley in 1816, when the author was 19. Well, first of all, its a total trip to watch it still. Comparing shelleys frankenstein and young frankenstein. How is the original frankenstein movie 1931 different from. Had i no self control, this answer would be the length of another novel.
The 1931 classic horror film frankenstein is what many of us think of when we think of the story of dr. This film is followed by the bride of frankenstein 1935, the son of frankenstein 1939, the ghost of frankenstein 1942, frankenstein meets the wolf man 1943, house of frankenstein 1944 and abbott and costello meet frankenstein 1948. Frankenstein is a film about a mad, obsessed scientist, dr. What are the essential differences between the frankenstein novel. Free 1931 frankenstein essays and papers 123helpme. Victor frankenstein movie wants to have more fun than the. Im writing a compare and contrast essay on frankenstein the book and frankenstein the movie 1931 version. This movie also spawned several b movie spinoffs such as the bride of frankenstein, 1935, and son of frankenstein, 1939.
Are there any similarities between the book frankenstein and. Is it calvin floyds terror of frankenstein or is it the tv movie frankenstein. The character of an assistant first appeared in 1931s frankenstein film in the form of fritz, before being codified, ironically enough, by mel brooks spoof film son of frankenstein. Frankenstein and his monster have been portrayed in a book and in movies. What film adaptation of frankenstein is the closest to mary shelleys book.
The basis for differences between mary shelleys frankenstein book and james whales 1931 movieli the plot structure in the book vs the movie. Slowly, the hand moves and frankenstein, overcome with joy, delivers the famous line. Im writing a compare and contrast essay on frankenstein the. Frankenstein 1931 published on october 28, 2011, by jproscoe posted in movies 0. Similarities include character, mood, and plot, though even within these there are numerous differences. Frankenstein, like todd brownings dracula released earlier the same year 1931, a landmark year which also saw the release of fritz langs dazzling serial killer thriller m. This is because, the movie is mainly based on the 1920s play, other than the original mary. In shelleys novel, as well as the 1931 film frankenstein, the doctor is about to. Or is there another film that is closest to the book. Moviechat forums frankenstein 1931 discussion you gotta admit, the movie does pale whe. Frankenstein lets them in to witness the final experiment. Compare and contrast frankenstein the book and movie essays. Frankenstein by mary shelley has been reproduced many times in the form of both book and film.
Frankensteins monster novel vs the 1931 movie youtube. Jul 30, 2011 what film adaptation of frankenstein is the closest to mary shelleys book. Im writing a compare and contrast essay on frankenstein. This movie also spawned several bmovie spinoffs such as the bride of frankenstein, 1935, and son of frankenstein, 1939. The same machinery reappeared years later in the fabulous mel brooks homage young frankenstein. Frankenstein is a fictional story written by mary shelly. For the sake of my sanity, i will limit the differences to the essential. In 1931, over a hundred years after publication of mary shelleys frankenstein, the first movie adaption of the novel was released. Listing five differences from mary shelleys frankenstein novel and its. Whats the difference between frankenstein or the modern prometheus the book and mary shelleys frankenstein the movie. In the book, the doctor betrayed his creation first by abandoning it immediately after granting it life, then by destroying a.
Although in both movies and the book frankenstein is portrayed as a monster there are many different perceptions about of him. This was supposed to be the original 1818 version of the book, but it isnt. This is assuming you are referring to 1931s frankenstein. Mary shelleys frankenstein book vs movie add a difference.
Frankenstein was an instant success and sold more copies than any book had before. I compared the first few chapters to an online version of the 1818 book and i noticed differences in letter 3 where a whole paragraph was added. I know, i know, frankenstein is the name of the man who creates the monster, not the monster itself. The movie and the book are the same in the way he created the monster. Differences between mary shelleys frankenstein book vs. What books would you compare to frankenstein by mary shelley. In the film, frankensteins assistant also absent in original novel steals a brain to use for the monster. Comparing the creation scene in james whales 1931 frankenstein and kenneth brannaghs 1994 frankenstein comparing the creation scene in james whales 1931 frankenstein and kenneth brannaghs 1994 frankenstein james whales 1931 portrayal of frankenstein when compared to kenneth brannaghs alternate account from 1994 reveals some similarities but also many differences in the. There is a 1910 version of frankenstein that was really nothing to write home about. Frankenstein is a 1931 american precode science fiction horror film directed by james whale, produced by carl laemmle jr. Victor frankenstein, spending what looks like its entire runtime on about a. The exclusion of several perspectives in the 1931 film, frankenstein, changes the story entirely.
Although these are all clear differences between the movie and book, one of the most prominent differences is the movies lack of layers and perspectives. Thats the 1931 boris karloff frankenstein, of course. Frankenstein is a 1931 american precode science fiction horror film directed by james whale. This doesnt happen in the book, and the decision to make this the. It was called frankenstein and had boris karloff as the creature. The novel, which follows a scientist named frankenstein and the horrifying creature he creates, explores the pursuit of knowledge and its consequences, as well as the human desire for connection and community. Whale may have made these changes as a way of speculating, after all the advancements in science, how it might be possible to create life and to satisfy his own. We get this lumbering, green hulk of a thing with bolt. Frankenstein, by mary shelley, is a classic horror novel and a prime example of the gothic genre. It was later adapted into a movie version directed by james whales.
Victor discovers the secret to creating life after examining the deceased professor waldmans research. From the very beginning of the film the differences are numerous victor frankensteins name isnt victor in the movie its henry. Nov 27, 2011 the ending of the novel is very different from the movie. A comparison of film and novel versions of frankenstein. The footage would be recycled throughout all of universals frankenstein films.
Comparing and contrasting shelleys frankenstein with brooks young frankenstein 1031 words 5 pages. There are more differences than similarities between the book and the movie. How is the original frankenstein movie 1931 different from the. In the movie, frankenstein lives with his fiance and the monster is hinted to be destroyed. Frankenstein 1931 film critique and analysis lusina. Are there any similarities between the book frankenstein and the 1931 movie. Its dated in some ways, for sure, and is low budget and that shows sometimes. In movies the monster will not stop at anything he was only out to hurt or destroy others as appose to the book where he tried to make friends and find someone to cherish and love. Best frankenstein film that was closest to the mary. Compare and contrast frankenstein book and movie essay anyone who has read mary shelleys frankenstein and seen james whale s 1931 film version knows that the similarities between the two are minuscule at best, while the differences abound. Examine the difference between the original novel and two movies from the. Get an answer for are there any similarities between the book frankenstein and the 1931 movie version.
The character has the same name in both the book and the movie. In the movie, frankenstein experimented only with dead animals, a human heartkept beating for three weeks, bodies took from graves, the gallows frankenstein. Horror stories are designed to entertain people by causing enjoyable feelings of. Are there any similarities between the book frankenstein. But millions of kids around the world who scream its frankenstein.
Comparing the creation scene in james whales 1931 frankenstein and kenneth brannaghs 1994 frankenstein comparing the creation scene in james whales 1931 frankenstein and kenneth brannaghs 1994 frankenstein james whales 1931 portrayal of frankenstein when compared to kenneth brannaghs alternate account from 1994 reveals some similarities but also many differences in the way they try. Balderston and the screenplay written by francis edward faragoh and garrett fort, with uncredited. Are there any similarities between the book frankenstein and the. Also, neither in the book nor in the movie is there any evidence that frankenstein had gone past the medical student stage. The absence of narration by all three characters, walton, frankenstein and the monster, changes the movie entirely from the book making it less complex and less interesting. With colin clive, mae clarke, boris karloff, john boles. What are the essential differences between the frankenstein novel with the movie. Mary shelleys frankenstein different film techniques compare and contrast the way in which the directors of mary shelleys frankenstein 1994 and frankenstein 1931 use different film techniques to build up atmosphere in their opening sequences. Victor frankenstein, spending what looks like its entire runtime on about a quarter to a third. Of the two early film adaptations of frankenstein, the bride of frankenstein, the sequel to the 1931 film, starring boris karloff and released in 1935 by universal, is much more faithful to the. Published in 1818, frankenstein tells the story of an ambitious scientist and the monster he creates.
Differences between mary shelleys frankenstein book vs movie. The movie keeps certain ideas from the movie intact to ensure the movie remains attached to the book. It creates an atmosphere of tension for the readeraudience. What are the essential differences between the frankenstein. Another difference is that the movie changes the main characters name. Frankenstein 1931 film news newspapers books scholar jstor may 2019 learn how and. Frankenstein adaptations are almost never frankenstein. Victor frankenstein movie wants to have more fun than the book did.
A brilliant pyrotechnic show follows, and the body is brought back down. The movie is a great classic and easy to watch but the novel is just a masterpiece. The book does not say the monster had electrodes on his neck, but it doesnt say he doesnt either. In other movies before or after frankenstein 1931 she is credited with her name or her full name mary wollstonecraft shelley. Difference in details of bringing the monster to life. In the book the victors father was a businessman and in the movie the father was a doctor, which was pretty different but it was not a dramatic difference. And i will try to keep them free of strong opinions.
In the book, victor frankenstein is the main character and in the movie, his grandson, fredrick frankenstein, is the protagonist. News the latest film adaptation victor frankenstein is. For the best answers, search on this site shelleys frankenstein is an example of the style of romanticism, so you might try comparing it to another book in the same style, for example thoreaus walden, since they are likely to have similar themes. The true story or the more recent mary shelleys frankenstein with robert deniro. You gotta admit, the movie does pale when compared to the. Shelley, mary frankenstein, the novel and the film. When james whale adopted the movie frankenstein from the original novel by mary shelley, the film gained the limelight while blurring the original novel. The movie keeps certain ideas from the movie intact to ensure the movie remains attached to the. The rest of the novel recounts frankensteins story, as told to the captain. The electrical machinery in dr frankensteins laboratory was provided by kenneth strickfaden. A bigger difference was that in the book alphonso frankenstein, victor. When compared to dracula, it looks and sound superior. Which is a shame, because the movie actually deviates very.
Compare and contrast frankenstein book and movie essay. This difference in the movie and book is the difference between deciding whether or not the monster should be considered human. Frankenstein tells the story of victor frankenstein, a scientist whose main ambition is to uncover the source of life. The 1931 black and white film of frankenstein has very few similarities to the original story written by mary shelley. There, frankenstein tells the tale of how he got here, turning the entire book into. There was no hunchback named igor in the 1931 frankenstein movie. In shelleys novel, as well as the 1931 film frankenstein, the doctor is about to marry. The most specific difference between the book and the movie is the acceptance of the creature as a man rather than a monster, which has led to the naming by some peoples account as misnaming of the creature as frankenstein. Frankenstein runs away, and when he returns, the creature has fled. Comparison between the film and the book frankenstein 123. For people with less than seven hours to spend on a podcast at the moment youre missing out, seriously, you can try documentaries and commentaries included on the frankenstein bluray and dvd sets, fan appreciations like monster madness, biographies of the likes of boris karloff, mae clarke, and james whale, or, hell, just go to the imdb.
Of mice and men compare and contrast the book, of mice and men by john steinbeck, is about two men named george and lennie who are living in the time of the great depression. Compare and contrast frankenstein the book and movie. Comparing and contrasting shelleys frankenstein with brooks young frankenstein the 1818 book frankenstein by mary shelley and the 1972 movie young frankenstein by mel brooks both portray the differences in feminism regarding the cultural times through the character of elizabeth. In the movie through his own studies and experiments, victor frankenstein develops a secret way of artificially creating life. Directed by james whale and written by peggy webling, the movie stars colin clive as henry frankenstein victor frankenstein, john boles as victor moritz henry clerval, and boris karloff as frankensteins monster. In shelleys novel, as well as the 1931 film frankenstein, the doctor is about to marry the lovely elizabeth. Another similarity between that film and the novel is that dr. What books would you compare to frankenstein by mary. Focusing on the differences between the 1931 movie frankenstein and the original novel, there are three main differences. This film is largely based on the 1920s play by peggy webling rather than the original shelley text. Another part of the movie that was the same as the book was when the monster tried to go kill elizabeth. A comparison of film and novel versions of frankenstein the nature of horror stories gives the readeraudience a feeling of intense fear, shock or disgust. Of course, the movie was a trendsetter in more ways than one, and features one of cinemas alltime finest performances from boris karloff as the tragic frankenstein monster, whilst whales inventive direction, the splendid sets, the awesome makeup, and colin clives hysterical turn as henry also contribute to the movies overall effect.
The ending of the novel is very different from the movie. Frankenstein cliffsnotes study guides book summaries. Mary shelleys gothic novel frankenstein is a story constantly being retold. Mary shelleys frankenstein is a 19thcentury epistolary novel associated with both the romantic and the gothic genres. Frankenstein 1931 there is a problem with a movie like this of what to say that hasnt been said. It looks and feels exactly what you expect from an old horror movie.
Mar 12, 2019 he kept the experiment entirely secret and had no outside help at all. And, of course, boris karloffs performance as the monster is the gold standard in filmdom to this day. Summary frankenstein was made in 1931 and was directed by james whale. Dec 26, 2009 what books would you compare to frankenstein by mary shelley. The difference between the book mary shelly frankenstein. Novelmovie difference mary shelleys frankenstein essay. Comparing frankensteins monster in mary shelleys 1818 novel to the 1931 universal movie. The unnamed creature is a tragic figure who becomes violent and murderous after being rejected by society.
278 416 19 1602 280 1065 1251 740 1361 589 528 1373 1226 186 97 1286 334 819 1147 935 132 1339 1006 799 1059 837 632 1188 654 404 1457 178